As the Paloni siblings, Leroy, Reggie, and Cheruce, prepare to host their Halloween special, they each come up with a set of spooky shorts to showcase from a group of talented up-and-coming animators. Leroy's short follows a young witch who must confront her fears in order to save her friends from a mysterious curse. Reggie's short tells the story of a ghost who haunts a lonely mansion, searching for answers from his past. Cheruce's short revolves around a group of friends who stumble upon a haunted carnival and must find a way to escape before it's too late.
As the show goes on, eerie happenings begin to occur both on and off screen, leading the Paloni siblings to question whether the animators' stories are purely fiction or if there may be some truth to the supernatural elements they depict. As the night progresses, the boundaries between reality and fantasy blur, and the siblings must confront their own fears in order to bring the Halloween special to a close. Ultimately, they learn that sometimes the scariest stories are the ones that hit closest to home.