As Evie fills out the list, she finds herself being more honest about her desires, including her longing for Jace. However, she accidentally leaves the Naughty List at the bar, and it falls into the wrong hands - namely, Jace's.
Jace is surprised to discover that Evie has a crush on him, and he starts to see her in a new light. Despite their age difference and the fact that they work together, he can't deny that he's attracted to her as well.
As the holiday season approaches, Jace decides to play a little game with Evie. He anonymously leaves her gifts each night, each one a tantalizing hint of what he wants to do to her. Evie is both thrilled and nervous about the mysterious suitor, not realizing that it's Jace all along.
As their flirtation heats up, Evie and Jace must decide if they can take their relationship to the next level or risk ruining everything they've built at The Black Diamond Bar. Will they stay on the Naughty List or finally graduate to the Nice List?