As the friends continue to party in the state park, they begin to experience strange occurrences and sightings of the ghostly figure of Caroline Woodman. Maddie becomes increasingly haunted by the spirit, feeling guilty for participating in the cruel dare that led to Caroline's death.
As the night goes on, the friends realize they are being hunted by Caroline's vengeful spirit, who seems determined to exact revenge on all those who wronged her. Panic sets in as they struggle to find a way to appease the angry ghost and put an end to the supernatural attacks.
In a desperate attempt to save themselves, the group must uncover the truth behind Caroline's tragic death and find a way to stop her relentless pursuit of revenge. They soon discover that Caroline's spirit cannot be killed, but they may be able to banish her from the park if they can find a way to release her from her torment.
As time runs out and the body count rises, the friends must band together and confront their own guilt and fears in order to survive the night and put an end to the curse of the "Girl Who Cried Her Eyes Out."