Genie Burns is the go-to woman for organizing the most outrageous surprise parties in town. She is known for her creativity and ability to pull off the most jaw-dropping surprises in the most unconventional locations. However, in her personal life, Genie tends to play it safe, especially when it comes to relationships.
Her best friend Steven, who is openly gay, is her trusted partner in running Surprise Enterprise. He is not afraid to call her out on her issues and push her out of her comfort zone. While Genie values Steven's friendship, she keeps him in the strictly platonic zone.
Enter Danny, Genie's college friend who has always been there for her. He is kind, reliable, and everything Genie could ask for in a partner. However, she is hesitant to take their relationship to the next level as she fears losing their strong friendship.
Everything changes when Jeff comes into the picture. Jeff is the complete opposite of Genie's usual type - he is spontaneous, adventurous, and challenges her fears head-on. His charm and depth draw Genie in, leaving her torn between staying in her comfortable safe zone or taking a chance on something new and exciting.
As Genie navigates her feelings for Jeff and grapples with her fears and insecurities, she realizes that sometimes the greatest surprises come from unexpected places. Will Genie choose to play it safe with Danny or take a leap of faith with Jeff, even if it means facing her deepest fears? Ultimately, she must decide if Jeff is the right one for her because he challenges her fears or the wrong one because he implodes them.