In Nostalgic Christmas, Anne (Brooke D'Orsay) helps her father Tom (Trevor Donovan) close their family's toy store after it fails to make a profit during the holiday season. However, while packing up the store, Anne discovers a box of Christmas memories that reminds her of the joy and magic of the holiday season. She also meets a young girl named Taylor (Lucia Walters) who is in need of some Christmas cheer after her own family's struggles.
Inspired by her own rediscovered Christmas spirit, Anne decides to help Taylor and her family, as well as the entire town, get into the holiday spirit by organizing a town-wide Christmas celebration. She enlists the help of her old friend and love interest Michael (Marcus Rosner) to make the event a success and bring joy to her community.
Throughout the course of the film, Anne learns the true meaning of Christmas and the importance of community, as she works to spread holiday cheer and bring people together. With heartwarming moments and a message of hope, Nostalgic Christmas is a perfect feel-good movie for the holiday season.