Christin is the owner of a quaint toy store located on a historic wharf in Nantucket. She is passionate about preserving the charm and character of the area, which is a popular destination for tourists and locals alike. When news spreads that a developer is planning to tear down the wharf to make way for a high-rise hotel, Christin is distraught.
Despite her anger towards the developer and his plans, Christin surprisingly finds herself attracted to his son, Andy. As tensions between the two families escalate, Christin and Andy begin to fall in love. However, their relationship is complicated by the fact that Christin is fighting against Andy's father's project, which could potentially harm the community she loves.
As the holiday season and the Seaside Noel celebrations draw closer, Christin and Andy must find a way to balance their growing feelings for one another with their opposing loyalties. With the future of the wharf at stake, and with their families on opposite sides of the conflict, Christin and Andy must navigate their way through the pressure and make the decision that is right for them and their community.