Maggie is a successful editor at a book publishing company, but her personal life is not as fulfilling as her professional life. She has been single for a while and is feeling lonely, especially during the holiday season. When her boss Amanda asks her to help find a date for the Christmas party, Maggie sees it as a chance to play matchmaker and hopefully find herself a date too.
However, her plans are thrown off when Jaxson, her old college boyfriend, shows up at her office as a newly signed author. Maggie is shocked to see Jaxson and still has feelings for him, but she tries to keep it professional and focus on her matchmaking duties. As she spends more time with Jaxson, she realizes that her feelings for him are still strong and she is unsure of what to do.
Meanwhile, Amanda is also interested in Jaxson and Maggie finds herself in the middle of a love triangle. She has to navigate her own feelings and the feelings of her boss to bring together the perfect matches for the Christmas party.
As the party approaches, Maggie has to make a decision about Jaxson and confront her past mistakes. She realizes that she needs to follow her heart and go after what she truly wants. In the end, Maggie finds love and Amanda finds a perfect match, making it a successful Christmas party for everyone involved.