Hannah is devastated after her boyfriend abruptly ends their relationship just weeks before Christmas. In addition, her dating app, Perfect One, is not doing well, and her business is on the brink of failure. Despite her desire to stay in the city, she decides to take a break and head home for Christmas.
Once she arrives home, Hannah quickly runs into her high school crush and former boyfriend, Sam. Sam had never left the small town, and he's still working at the same job he had in high school. Although Hannah initially tries to avoid him, she eventually runs into him at the town's Christmas Cupid event. The Christmas Cupid event is a longstanding town tradition where people sign up to be anonymous pen pals to get a chance to connect with someone they might not have met before.
Hannah agrees to sign up for the Christmas Cupid event at the behest of her father, who believes that it could help her get over her ex-boyfriend. Hannah eagerly waits for her first letter, and when it arrives, she's immediately smitten by the elegant prose and charming personality of her anonymous pen pal.
As the weeks pass, Hannah becomes more and more enamored with her pen pal. She begins to suspect that she may have found her soulmate and becomes fixated on uncovering his identity. However, as she races to find him, she finds that there are roadblocks in her path that she never considered, making the path to true love complicated and full of unexpected surprises.
Despite the obstacles she faces along the way, Hannah ultimately finds a way to find her Christmas pen pal, and the two of them enjoy a happy and memorable holiday season together. Christmas Pen Pals is a heartwarming romance that highlights the magic and warmth of the holiday season.
