In Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reunited and It Feels So Deadly, Aurora Teagarden, a librarian and crime buff, attends her high school reunion at a luxurious hotel with her old classmates. However, their enjoyment is interrupted when a body is found floating in the hotel pool.
Aurora and her Real Murders Club, which includes her boyfriend Nick and her best friend Sally, are determined to solve the case and find out who among their former classmates could be a killer.
As they investigate, they uncover secrets and motives that point to several suspects, including a wealthy businessman, a successful real estate agent, and a famous actress. Aurora also discovers that her own past is connected to the murder, making her a target for the killer.
With the help of Nick and Sally, Aurora races against time to catch the killer before they strike again. As they piece together the clues, they realize that the killer is closer than they think and that their own lives may be in danger.
In the end, Aurora and her friends confront the killer and reveal the truth behind the murder that had haunted them for years. Aurora also learns some surprising truths about her past and decides to make some life-changing decisions.