Holly is a young woman who has grown up in a quaint, small town. She works at the local gift shop and spends her free time volunteering at the community center. Holly is a hopeless romantic and dreams of finding her soulmate one day. Chris, on the other hand, is a successful businessman from the city. He is career-driven and doesn't believe in love at first sight.
Holly's great-aunt, who happens to be a matchmaking guru, decides to set Holly up with Chris. She thinks they would be a perfect match despite their different personalities. At first, Holly and Chris are hesitant about the idea of being set up. However, they both decide to give it a chance and go on a date.
During their date, Holly and Chris discover they have more in common than they thought. They both enjoy hiking, cooking, and watching old movies. They quickly begin to fall for each other. But as the holiday season approaches, Holly's job and family responsibilities start to take up most of her time, making it hard for her to balance her relationship with Chris.
As tensions rise, Holly and Chris must decide if they're willing to make sacrifices to be with each other. They must work together to find a way to overcome their differences and make their relationship work. As the movie comes to a close, Holly and Chris realize that sometimes love is worth taking a chance on, even if it means stepping out of their comfort zones.